In August 2000, while in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, Renfro (18 years old at the time) and a friend tried to steal a 45-foot luxury yacht valued at $175,000, but the pair forgot to untie the yacht from the dock and as they pulled away, it bounced back, causing damage to the stern. Those around who heard the disturbance held the two teens until the police arrived. He was charged with grand theft. In 2001, he was put on two years probation and ordered to pay more that $4,000 for the damages on the yacht.

