1. Home
  2. News & Issues
  3. Crime / Punishment

Stanley 'Tookie' Williams' Defense at Trial

Jury Rejects Alibi Testimony

By , About.com Guide

Jul 2 2006
In contrast to the overwhelming evidence presented to the jury which established Stanley 'Tookie' Williams' guilt, the defense consisted of Williams' step-father, two inmates that were housed in jail with Williams, and Williams' girlfriend. The testimony of these various individuals was soundly rejected by the jury.

Here are details from the Los Angeles District Attorney's office:

Fred Holiwell

Holiwell, the step-father of Stanley Williams, testified that he saw Williams at the Showcase club at Sunday, March 11, 1979. However, Holiwell was not at all sure as to the time he saw Williams. Holiwell, when initially interviewed by the police, said he saw Williams between 3:00 a.m. and 4:00 a.m. and that Williams then left. (TT 2621).

However, under questioning by the defense, Holiwell said it could have been "around 5:00 or 5:15" in the morning, but he didn't "take note of the exact time" that he saw him. (TT 2614). Then, Holiwell said he didn't know when Williams left, explaining "I was in the back of my camper. So, how could I really see if he left?" (TT 2622).

Holiwell then admitted that he initially told the deputies that "he did not know how the defendant left." (TT 2622). Then, Holiwell even admitted that he never said he "definitely" saw Williams. Instead, he said he thought he saw him (TT 2622) but was "not sure." (TT 2625).

Eugene Riley

Eugene Riley was a county jail inmate who, prior to trial, had been housed with and had spoken with Williams. (TT 2640). He claimed he saw Williams at the Showcase at "about 5:30" in the morning on Sunday, March 11, 1979. (TT 2642). After watching Williams smoke a sherm (PCP cigarette), he drove Williams to the home of James Garrett. (TT 2644).

The next time he claimed to have seen Williams was in 1981, when they were both housed together in jail. (TT 2645). At that time, Williams and Riley spoke about Riley testifying as a witness for Williams. (TT 2646).

However, prior to that conversation, Riley admitted he had never previously talked about the night of March 11, 1979, and he had never heard of the Brookhaven murders. (TT 2658). As such, Riley was unable to explain how he was able to recall these events. The only logical explanation, and surely the explanation drawn by the jury, was that Williams spoke with Riley in jail and told him what to say on the stand.

Joseph McFarland

Joseph McFarland, who had previously been convicted of seven felonies (Penal Code 664/211) was also a county jail inmate who, prior to trial, had been housed with and had spoken with both Stanley Williams and Eugene Riley. (TT 2677, 2693, 2725, 2729). McFarland testified that George Oglesby was a "jailhouse rat" (TT 2683) and that some inmates gave Oglesby fake information, knowing he would take it to the deputies. (TT 2684).

However, McFarland admitted he did not know what Williams had told Oglesby. (TT 2742). McFarland also testified that Williams did pass an escape note to Oglesby. (TT 2693-2694, 2697). Lastly, McFarland testified that Williams told him (McFarland) about the notes and that he (Williams) wanted McFarland to testify about them. (TT 2699).

Beverly McGowan

Beverly McGowan testified that on February 27, 1979, Williams came over to her house for dinner and then he spent the night. (TT 2750). She claimed that although they saw each other regularly, she never saw Williams again after the morning of February 28, 1979. (TT 2752, 2755). McGowan admitted that since Williams was arrested, she had visited him regularly in jail and that he had asked her to help him with his case. (TT 2752-2754, 2757, 2763).

Next: Founder of the Crips Street Gang

Explore Crime / Punishment

About.com Special Features

Holiday Central

What to eat, where to go, fun things to do and how to save money on the perfect gifts. More >

Weird Breaking News

A daily look at some of the oddest (and dumbest) crimes around. More >

  1. Home
  2. News & Issues
  3. Crime / Punishment

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.