1. News & Issues

Discuss in my forum

Readers Respond: What Do You Think Happened to Caylee Anthony?

Responses: 271

By , About.com Guide

My scenerio..

First, Cindy Anthony, in all of her denial & stupidity, is not responsible whatsoever for her Granddaughter's demise. Remember, she's the one who ultimately called police & reported Caylee missing immediately after she heard Casey tell Lee she had been kidnapped by the non~exsistant Zanny the Nanny. Those who blame that woman for Caylee's death are being beyond ridiculous. Dog her for lying after the fact all day long, just don't confuse it for her being to blame for her sick twisted daughter. I can't even imagine being in her shoes & I would never pretend to know what something like this would do to my psyche. How awful. George Anthony also had nothing but pure love for his kids & Caylee that was un~conditional & genuine. He did not deserve to go thru the hell of his daughter killing his granddaughter or the disgusting lies & accusations f/m the defense & the millions of people judging him f/m a distance. We're ALL pissed! But the blame should be placed where it belongs & that is NOT
—DarlingNikki10

nothing adds up

I think that not hearing from your grandchild in about 3 days you need to get off your butt and go check out what is going on. Cindy should of taken that baby away and they all are stupid for not protecting that baby. They all need to be in prison and maybe even worse they need to hurt like that baby might of. The fact that they are not so mad at Casey for her not taking care of that baby worriers me and that is why they all need to be in prison. I mean where is the protection that this baby should of had.
—Guest shallowhal321

This is what I believe

I believe she wanted Casey to "accidently" fall into the pool, that is what the ladder was doing in the pool when Cindy clearly remembered taking it out the night before, she left Caylee outside by herself hoping she would climb into the pool because Cindy stated how much Caylee liked to swim, hoping Caylee would slip in and drown, oh my, what a horrible accident. But when that didn't happen, Casey became impatient because she wanted to get her sex on with Tony and did it the fast way, with Chloroform. Whether or not Cindy and George were involved, I'm not sure, I love my children, but if one of them killed their children, I would be the first one on the phone to the police. God Bless Caylee.
—marymcq

How Caylee Died - 3

A thousand thoughts ran through NOT MOM's head. She came to reason that she would have to put Caylee somewhere until she figured out what to do. She knew that carrying her back out to the car might allow for hr to be seen. Looking around, her eyes fell on a laundry bag. That would do for now. With Caylee secured in the laundry bag, NOT MOM walked out to her car and opened the trunk. She tossed the laundry bag into the trunk as if it were clothing just in case someone was watching. NOT MOM then got into her car and drove over to her boyfriends house. They snuggled, they ate, then they went out and rented movies. Caylee lay decaying in the trunk of the car for several days.
—VsulEfx

How Caylee Died - 2

NOT MOM got back in the car and drove to her Mothers house. Caylee was quiet. It wasn't until she pulled into the driveway and got out that she noticed Caylee laying over to the side, blue in the face. She had been unable to free herself from the duct tape. Caylee was dead. NOT MOM tried repeatedly to call her Mother. There was no answer. Realizing that she could go to jail for the rest of her life, NOT MOM removed Caylee from the car and took her inside. She carefully wrapped Caylee in her blanket.
—VsulEfx

How Caylee Died

It was almost dinner time. Caylee was cranky, she was hungry, and NOT MOM was annoyed. As they drove out of the Walmart parking lot NOT MOM screamed at Caylee to be quiet. She was trying to drive and text at the same time. A short way down the road Caylee began bumping the back of the car seat with her foot. NOT MOM became more and more enraged with every thump. NOT MOM pulled over, got out of the car, opened Caylee's door and took her from the car seat. She spanked her across her leg, causing the tired and hungry Caylee to scream and strike back. NOT MOM lost control and struck the child hard across the face. She grabbed Caylee up, threw her back into the car seat...and noticed a roll of duct tape in the floorboard under Caylees feet. She quickly ripped off three pieces and taped up Caylees mouth, covering her nose.
—VsulEfx

theory

My theory is that there was an argument on the night of the 15th between Casey and CIndy, as the neighbors stated, over the money that Casey stole from her gparents. Casey took Caylee, determined that Cindy would never see her again. She cholorformed Caylee because she was going to spend the night at Tony's. Hoping Caylee would sleep in the trunk through the night, but realized in the am that she went too far. I think George either confused the dates (or lied) about the last time he saw Casey and Caylee. Casey then left the body in the trunk trying to figure out how to dispose of the body. Tried digging in the backyard but settled on the swamp instead. She packed her in trash bags and used the tape to keep the body fluids from leaking out, had her in the car trunk prior to dumping her on the side of the road. Either way, accident or intentional, Casey should be held responsible. What a shame she was given a free ride... hopefully she will never live the beautiful life.
—kaybee2510

The Real Truth.

This is it people. Casey had been knocking Caylee out for quite awhile with either Xanaz, Benadryl or Chloroform in order to go out. She would then say the child was in the care of a Nanny (Zanny). Since2006.... terrible thought. She was lying about the child,work, etc and she was stealing money during this time from her Grandparents, Amy, and her parents. Casey's mother was coming to the end of her rope with all of it. We can not underestimate the importance of Casey's love for new boyfriend Tony Lazzaro, the club promoter who lived a very carefree life and was not interested in children (text transcripts attest to this). Casey got so tired of trying keep her game in check and juggle Caylee, Tony, her lies, partying w/increasing pressure from Mom. She loved Caylee but started focusing on the fact that she should have aborted Caylee. This is her motive. She drugged Caylee, duct taped her and then paniced a bit about where to put her before finally dumping her in the woods.
—Guest Insider

The party girl

I also believe she was giving Cylee the Xanex probably leaving her in the car asleep , while she was partying - but this time the heat got to Cylee , and Casey paniced .. took her to her parent and put her in the laundry bag -then placed her in the trunk of her car -- how am I going to explain this .. rather be partying then careing for this kid .... the Cylees jaw dropped so got out the duct tape to hold her jaw in place .. the smell is getting bad need to find a place to hide the body - so takes her up the road aways .. theres a party and she wants her friends to go -- the car can't smell like a dead body ... so before she goes out she heads to the woods ... and still has'nt reported her missing or injured ... and her mother is asking question???? WHERE IS CYLEE?
—Guest misty

Who To Blame

Yea, the jury pleaded her Not Guilty, But In my Opinion, i think Thats just not right. People such as the jury needs to realise that a Little Girl has been Murdered!! She hasn't even lived. Thats just sad, i don't know her, and i've just heard of her yesterday! & makes me think 'what has this world become?!" Who ever murdered Caylee, must a cold hearted, evil person. To some people, the mother killed her, To other people Some stranger killed her, well who ever murdured her must be ashame of themselves, must have regrets. & just think of 'what if' Or "if she was alive. . ." Rip in Peace Caylee :)
—Guest Gloria

Wanted to Sedate Her and Went to Far

I believe she was giving her Xanex for awhile to put her to sleep and this time went too far and Casey panicked and did not really know what the right thing to do at that point. She obviously is not the sharpest tool in the shed! She did the wrong thing and went on and on about lies and could never admit to the truth because she also in narcissistic and only really cares about what is good for her. She never should have had the child. She should of given her to a couple that would have loved her and put her first like most real mothers do!
—Guest JADE

A question unanswered

My question that never was answered was where was Caylee in the PAST when she was supposed to be with Zanny? I think that it was in 2006 when Casey first mentioned Zanny to her mother, so my question is if Casey didn't have her, Cindy didn't have her, and make believe Zanny didn't have her where was she? Chloroformed somewhere? Maybe at a friend’s apartment by herself with her mouth duct taped in case she woke up??
—Guest Florida girl

she did it duh !

i thank ha mama kiled ha kuz she aint kall da popo when ha baby waz missin..which waz a lie she knew caylee body was hiddin. nd 2 the jury aint find her guilty because money makes da world go round but one day we will soon find out the truth,casey anthony is going to slip up! eather she gone run her mouth about what she did or do something similar or jst simply do the same thing again. then comes karma!
—Guest amy

stan

The ground was to hard to dig and it was work that she can't do so she returned the shovel, drove down the street, dumped the body where she and others buried animals and saw two homes on the corner - one mail box had Zenaida on it the other had the name Gonzales on it.
—Guest stan

stan

ok this is how it was done casey /caylee 1250 in car 100 til 114 casey on phone with tony 115 til 300casey and tony kills caylee no ok 300 casey calls dads cell 308 calls tony 335 calls tony now caylee is swimmg and drowns or casey puts duck tape over her now from 410 425 a lot of calls like something is wrong 425 til 557 plannig what to do dont went to break planes its all about me why care for a little kid that died did not care she was missing 557 casey calls tony ill be home soon 621 calls mom cell 632 and 700 calls the house to lie about somethig 758 casey and tony at blockbuster that was june 16 now june 18 caylee is in trunk murder at this time even if she drowned casye calls mom dad and home at1233.1234.1235.1236.109.111 to see if any one is home backs car in never did that befor but mom and dads car was in grage so she always park in driveway 130 borrows shovel from next door to dig up root they hurt her and caylees feet puts body on ground between the shield and playhouse
—Guest stan

Share Your Theory

What Do You Think Happened to Caylee Anthony?

Receive a one-time notification when your response is published.

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.